Authors for Biomedical or Legal Manuscripts :

Issues in Law and Medicine: A Journal of the Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine (ILM JAHM) publishes peer-reviewed scholarship at the intersection of health care, ethics, and law, with particular attention to the Hippocratic tradition of medicine and the care of the most vulnerable members of our communities. See About the Journal for the full scope.

SUBMIT A MANUSCRIPT

Biomedical research, Reviews, Organizational Guidelines and Ethical/Policy manuscripts are submitted here

Legal manuscripts are submitted through the legal submission site (click here).

ILM JAHM does not accept simultaneous submissions. Notify the editors if the manuscript is under review elsewhere. Disclose any prior publication of substantially similar material, including in a blog, working paper, or report. Submissions must be original and not previously published.

Editorial and Journal policies are available here: ILM JAHM Policies

ARTICLE TYPES, ORGANIZATION AND LENGTHS

ILM JAHM accepts concisely written manuscripts of various types up to 20,000 words. The word count excludes the abstract (up to 250 words), title page, tables and figures, and references.

Biomedical Clinical Intervention: These manuscripts report the results of clinical interventions with human or animal subjects and thus require IRB approval. These manuscripts should in general contain abstracts and main text organized around the following headings:
Introduction/literature review, Hypothesis, Methods, Results, Discussion and Conclusions.

Biomedical Database Research: These manuscripts utilize de-identified databases instead of human or animal subjects. De-identified database research does not require IRB approval. These manuscripts should also, in general, contain abstracts and main text organized around the following headings:
Introduction/literature review, Hypothesis, Methods, Results, Discussion and Conclusions.

Case Reports or Case Series: These manuscripts provide detailed reports of symptoms, diagnoses, treatments, and outcomes of patients, especially unique or novel cases. These manuscripts should contain abstracts and main text organized around the following headings: Introduction/Literature review, Case description and Discussion.

Biomedical Systematic Review or Meta-analysis: These manuscripts systematically identify and consolidate existing research, summarizing findings from multiple studies to provide a comprehensive overview. Meta-analyses also statistically combine the results of different studies. Review articles must state an a priori search strategy, along with criteria for article selection. Authors are urged to follow Cochrane, PRISMA or other standard formats.

Ethical or Policy Manuscripts: These manuscripts investigate ethical or policy topics pertaining to the practice of Hippocratic medicine. These manuscripts should contain an abstract and main text organized around the following headings: Introduction/Literature Review, Structure of the argument, Alternative Viewpoints and Conclusions.

Special Issues: ILM JAHM may publish special issues from time to time, with appropriate specific instructions for authors. Correspondence with the editors is suggested before submitting manuscripts for these issues.

Organizational Guidelines Organizational Guidelines. are manuscripts that have already been reviewed by the submitting organizations and are published in ILM JAHM as an “open peer-reviewed” document after final review by the Editorial Board of ILM JAHM. See detailed description of organizational guidelines publication criteria.

PREPARING YOUR MANUSCRIPT

Anonymizing your manuscript for review:
ILM JAHM uses double-anonymized review: reviewers do not know the authors’ identities, and authors do not know the reviewers’ identities. Remove names, affiliations, acknowledgments, and funding information from the main manuscript file, and strip identifying information from the document properties. Refer to your own work in the third person, and replace any citation of your own work with “Author citation removed for review.” Full citations are restored after acceptance.

Length:
Abstracts should be under 250 words. Main text word counts are up to 20,000 words, excluding the abstract, title page, tables and figures, and references. The editors may accept manuscripts outside these ranges when the subject warrants it.

Format:
Submit a Word file (.docx), double-spaced, in 12-point type, with endnote references in AMA style Number pages consecutively. Place tables and figures within the text where they are discussed.

Citation Style
ILM JAHM uses AMA style All references should have a DOI included with each reference. DOI’s can be found here.

Accuracy of authority:
Authors are responsible for the accuracy of every citation and quotation.

SUBMITTING YOUR MANUSCRIPT

When submitting your manuscript, the portal will require the following information:

Metadata
* Title
* Article type
* Abstract
* Keywords
* Competing-interest statement for all authors. A disclosed interest does not imply bias and is not by itself grounds for rejection. The editors evaluate each disclosure individually, and disclosures are published with accepted articles.

Author data

Files
* Anonymized manuscript
* Title page with title, each author’s name, institutional affiliation, and email, and identification of the corresponding author
* Cover letter (optional) explaining the manuscript’s contribution and noting any related work under review elsewhere
* Tables (optional) additional tables or figures not included in the main manuscript
* Supplementary Information (optional)
* Author biographies, for each author, up to 100 words for each bio.
* Research Ethics Documentation/IRB approval or waiver. Manuscripts reporting original research with human participants, such as surveys, interviews, or analysis of identifiable records, must document approval by an institutional review board or a formal exemption. De-identified database research does not require this documentation but must include documentation that the database is de-identified.
* Additional Files (optional)

Funding statement or a statement that the work received no specific funding

Authorship affirmation

MANUSCRIPT REVIEW PROCESS

When a manuscript has been submitted through the Scholastica portal, it will be reviewed by the Editor-in-Chief and Administrative Editor for scope and quality, typically within 2 weeks. Manuscripts outside the scope or not ready for review are declined without external review.

If the manuscript is accepted for review, an Associate Editor will be assigned. If an Associate Editor has a competing interest in a manuscript, they recuse themselves and another Associate Editor will manage the manuscript review process.

The Associate Editor invites at least two qualified subject matter reviewers, and may also invite a statistical reviewer if the manuscript warrants specialized statistical review.

ILM JAHM uses a double-anonymized review process: reviewers do not know the authors’ identities, and authors do not know the reviewers’ identities.

Reviewers evaluate a manuscript based on these specific questions:

  1. Mission Relevance :Is the topic and research within this manuscript relevant to the mission of ILM JAHM, which is to explore the intersection of health care, ethics, and law that affects the most vulnerable human beings in our communities?

  2. Research Question and Rationale :Is the research or ethical question clearly stated, and does the introduction establish why it matters?

  3. Approach :Is the study design or analytic framework appropriate to the question, and is it described in enough detail to be reproduced or critically evaluated?

  4. Discussion :Does the discussion incorporate the main points, adequately review the supporting and conflicting literature by including counter-arguments along with the strengths, weaknesses, and limitations of the work? Are normative claims clearly distinguished from empirical findings?

  5. Conclusions :Are the conclusions supported by the results or by the argument presented?

  6. Research Ethics for Human Subject Studies :Are ethics committee approval or exemption, informed consent, and de-identification of case material documented where applicable?

  7. References :Do the cited references demonstrate the significant work of others on the topic, including those with different findings?

  8. Presentation :Does the abstract accurately summarize the manuscript? Are the writing, tables, and figures clear?

  9. Contribution :Does the manuscript make an original and significant contribution to the existing literature?

  10. Study Population :Are the participants/ data sources clearly defined and selected in a way that limits selection bias, with a comparison group where indicated? Considerations: inclusion and exclusion criteria; the natural history or spontaneous improvement rate where relevant._

  11. Bias and Measurement :Are confounding variables addressed, and exposures, interventions and outcomes measured with valid methods?
    Considerations: whether outcome assessors were blinded where feasible.

  12. Results :Are the results complete and consistent with the methods, and all participants accounted for? Considerations: losses to follow-up, dropouts, missing data, and intention-to-treat analysis in randomized trials.

  13. Statistical Analysis :Is the analysis appropriate to the design and data, and is the study adequately powered for its conclusions? Considerations: sample size calculation; median and interquartile range and non-parametric or exact tests for small or skewed samples; an omnibus test before pairwise comparisons; adjustment for multiple comparisons and confounders; survival analysis for time-to-event data; effect sizes and their clinical relevance.

  14. Reporting Standards :Was an appropriate reporting guideline (for example CONSORT, STROBE or PRISMA) followed, and was the trial registered where applicable?

  15. Allocation :Is allocation to groups clearly described and appropriate to the study design? Considerations: the randomization method and allocation concealment in randomized trials; the basis for allocation in non-randomized and quasi-experimental designs.

  16. Harms and Benefits : Are adverse events reported, and are the risks and benefits of the intervention weighed?

  17. Search and Selection for Reviews :Are the search and study selection systematic, and is the available evidence considered in a balanced way?

  18. Quality of Evidence for Reviews :Is the quality or risk of bias of the included studies assessed and reported?

  19. Bioethics and Policy: Factual Accuracy :Are clinical and scientific claims, professional standards, and institutional policies accurately stated and sourced?

  20. Bioethics and Policy: Ethical Framework :Is the framework or method of analysis (for example, principlist, virtue-based, natural law, or casuistic) identified, and is its use justified?

  21. Bioethics and Policy: Practical Implications :Do recommendations for practice or policy follow from the analysis and are they feasible?

  22. Bioethics and Policy: Reasoning :Is the argument logically valid, and are key terms defined and used consistently? Considerations: whether terminology is neutral enough, and the tone respectful enough, for the argument to be judged on its merits.

  23. Bioethics and Policy: Persons Affected :Does the analysis consider those most affected, especially those most vulnerable or least able to advocate for themselves?

  24. Bioethics and Policy: Goods at Stake :Does the manuscript identify the goods or values at stake (for example, autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, justice, and human dignity), and does the manuscript explain how they are weighed when they conflict, and justify the author’s ordering?

Reviewers return recommendations, typically within 4–6 weeks. The Associate Editor compiles the reviews and then recommends acceptance, revision, or rejection to the Editor-in-Chief.

The Editor-in-Chief makes a final decision and communicates it to the authors via the Scholastica Portal, including the specific reviewer comments that must be addressed if a revision is recommended.

If a revision is recommended, then the authors should resubmit a revised manuscript including a response letter addressing each reviewer comment.

The revised manuscript may be sent back to the original reviewers, to new reviewers, or the Editor-in-Chief and Administrative Editor may decide the revision has satisfied the reviewer comments. The final decision to accept, revise, or reject is made by the Editor-in-Chief.

Authors may appeal a decision by writing to the editors within 30 days with a specific explanation of the grounds.

After acceptance. Accepted manuscripts are copyedited for style, citation form, and clarity. The corresponding author receives galley proofs and should return corrections within 48 hours; changes at proof stage are limited to errors.

Publication typically follows acceptance by about 3 weeks, depending on length and the author’s responsiveness. Each article receives a DOI.

Corrections and retractions. The ILM JAHM policy on retractions is modeled after COPE guidance. Errors discovered after publication are corrected through a linked notice. Concerns about a published article may be sent to ILMJAHMAdminEIC@proton.me.

FEES, LICENSING, AND PUBLICATION

Fees. ILM charges a nonrefundable $10 submission fee. There are no article processing or publication charges.

Copyright and license. Articles are published open access under a [Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY)] license.

CONTACT

Questions about submissions: ILMJAHMAdminEIC@proton.me. Status updates on a submitted manuscript are sent through the Scholastica portal.

Search